Bulbs Flower Basics Flower Beds & Specialty Gardens Flower Garden Garden Furniture Garden Gnomes Garden Seeds Garden Sheds Garden Statues Garden Tools & Supplies Gardening Basics Green & Organic Groundcovers & Vines Growing Annuals Growing Basil Growing Beans Growing Berries Growing Blueberries Growing Cactus Growing Corn Growing Cotton Growing Edibles Growing Flowers Growing Garlic Growing Grapes Growing Grass Growing Herbs Growing Jasmine Growing Mint Growing Mushrooms Orchids Growing Peanuts Growing Perennials Growing Plants Growing Rosemary Growing Roses Growing Strawberries Growing Sunflowers Growing Thyme Growing Tomatoes Growing Tulips Growing Vegetables Herb Basics Herb Garden Indoor Growing Landscaping Basics Landscaping Patios Landscaping Plants Landscaping Shrubs Landscaping Trees Landscaping Walks & Pathways Lawn Basics Lawn Maintenance Lawn Mowers Lawn Ornaments Lawn Planting Lawn Tools Outdoor Growing Overall Landscape Planning Pests, Weeds & Problems Plant Basics Rock Garden Rose Garden Shrubs Soil Specialty Gardens Trees Vegetable Garden Yard Maintenance

Can You Make Your Neighbor Trim a Tree if it Hangs Over Onto Your Property by California Law?

Can You Make Your Neighbor Trim a Tree if it Hangs Over Onto Your Property by California Law?

Can You Make Your Neighbor Trim a Tree if it Hangs Over Onto Your Property by California Law?. When your neighbor's tree overhangs your yard, don't go out on a limb. Although for decades California law permitted a neighbor to whack off roots and branches at the property line, a 1994 case smudged black and white case law into shades of gray.

When your neighbor's tree overhangs your yard, don't go out on a limb. Although for decades California law permitted a neighbor to whack off roots and branches at the property line, a 1994 case smudged black and white case law into shades of gray.
Former Law
For years, California landowners enjoyed an absolute right to cut encroaching tree branches at the boundary line or force their neighbors to do so. They relied on California Civil Code 829, which states that "[t]he owner of land in fee has the right to the surface and to everything permanently situated beneath or above it."
Booska v. Patel
The 1994 California case Booska v. Patel involved a property owner who sliced the roots of his neighbor's 40-year-old Monterey pine at the property line, rendering the tree unstable. The court rejected the position that the property owner had an absolute right to do so.
Expert Insight
Under Booska v. Patel, the right to remove -- or force your neighbor to remove -- infringing branches and roots is limited by the rule of reason. Randall Stamen, California attorney and arborist, recommends phoning your neighbor and finding a compromise.

Check out these related posts